Travel
Fact-checked

At WiseTour, we're committed to delivering accurate, trustworthy information. Our expert-authored content is rigorously fact-checked and sourced from credible authorities. Discover how we uphold the highest standards in providing you with reliable knowledge.

Learn more...

What Are the Pros and Cons of Using Hard Case Luggage?

Hard case luggage offers superior protection and durability, safeguarding your belongings against rough handling. However, it's often heavier and less flexible than soft bags, potentially leading to excess baggage fees. Plus, its rigid structure can limit packing capacity. Considering a luggage upgrade? Weigh the benefits against the drawbacks to see if a hard case is your travel ally. What's your take?
Sheri Cyprus
Sheri Cyprus

The advantages, or pros, of traveling with hard case luggage include the protective shell to keep your belongings from becoming crushed. The disadvantages, or cons, of this type of luggage are that its colors and patterns may be limited and it doesn't "squish" down or fit as easily into small spaces as the more decorative, soft-sided suitcases. Hard case luggage is also heavier and tends to show scuffs or scratches quite easily. Yet, the plastic or metal shell can stay cleaner and is typically much more durable than cloth or vinyl suitcases.

The tough, durable quality of hard shell travel cases is a popular pro. They can withstand a lot of handling by airport staff and are unlikely to become damaged. Many types of hard shell luggage are designed to take maximum impact and still hold up well. Most kinds of cloth suitcases, on the other hand, could become torn, pierced or have a damaged handle or pocket section after being taken on half as many travel adventures as hard case luggage. One con though is that if a hard shell suitcase becomes scratched, it can be more difficult, or even impossible, to repair the scratch than the damage typically done to cloth bags.

Hard case luggage is easier to clean than cloth or soft-sided luggage.
Hard case luggage is easier to clean than cloth or soft-sided luggage.

Yet, the bottom of a cloth bag left on the ground can much more easily become soiled with a stain than an easy-to-wipe hard surface suitcase. Hard case luggage also has the pro of being less likely to mildew from damp conditions than cloth suitcases or to smell as musty from the excess moisture. The shell of hard cases can typically be dried as easily as they can be wiped, while cloth luggage may become ruined from too much moisture. Whereas a hard suitcase surface protects the contents from water, a soft one does not.

Silver hard case luggage can be ultra-modern with a cool, streamlined appearance.
Silver hard case luggage can be ultra-modern with a cool, streamlined appearance.

Although cloth or nylon soft-sided luggage is available in more patterns and colors that the hard case variety, it often doesn't look as elegant or modern. For instance, silver hard case luggage in an interestingly textured metal can be ultra-modern with a cool, streamlined appearance. A con can be that hard shell suitcases in neutral colors can be more difficult to spot on luggage carousels than brightly colored or distinctly patterned cloth bags.

Hard case luggage doesn't easily fit into compartments the way soft luggage does.
Hard case luggage doesn't easily fit into compartments the way soft luggage does.

A con of some hard surface luggage pieces is that they can be much heavier than cloth cases. On the other hand, a pro is that many are available with extending handles, bottom wheels and other innovative features. For instance, hard case luggage may have smaller, more stylish and easier rolling wheels than those on soft suitcases. These smaller wheels may swivel or turn better as well.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main advantages of using hard case luggage?

A hard case piece of luggage may have rolling wheels that make it easy to transport.
A hard case piece of luggage may have rolling wheels that make it easy to transport.

Hard case luggage offers superior protection for your belongings, especially fragile items, due to its rigid exterior. It's also generally more water-resistant than soft luggage, safeguarding contents from the elements. Additionally, hard shells are easier to clean and can be more durable against the wear and tear of travel.

How does hard case luggage fare against impacts and rough handling?

Hard case luggage is designed to withstand impacts and rough handling better than soft luggage. The rigid shell distributes the force of impacts, reducing the risk of damage to the contents. However, hard cases can sometimes crack under extreme pressure or after sustaining multiple heavy blows.

Is hard case luggage heavier than soft luggage, and how does this affect airline weight limits?

Historically, hard case luggage was heavier than soft luggage, but with advancements in materials like polycarbonate, modern hard cases are much lighter. Still, they may weigh slightly more than soft bags, potentially affecting how much you can pack before hitting airline weight limits.

Can hard case luggage be less convenient for storage and packing flexibility?

Yes, hard case luggage can be less flexible when it comes to packing irregular-shaped items, and they don't offer the same expandability as soft luggage. Storage can also be an issue since they don't compress or collapse, requiring more space in your home or hotel room.

Are there any security benefits to using hard case luggage?

Hard case luggage often comes with integrated locks, which can provide an added level of security compared to soft luggage. The hard shell itself is also more difficult to tamper with or cut open, offering better protection against theft.

You might also Like

Discussion Comments

Stelando
I'm a soft-sided luggage fan, personally. It just doesn't feel like packing if I'm not standing on top of my soft bag, jumping up and down, and defying the laws of physics by narrowly zipping that bag shut. Don't think you could work that kind of magic with a hard bag.
Post your comments
Login:
Forgot password?
Register:
    • Hard case luggage is easier to clean than cloth or soft-sided luggage.
      By: monticellllo
      Hard case luggage is easier to clean than cloth or soft-sided luggage.
    • Silver hard case luggage can be ultra-modern with a cool, streamlined appearance.
      By: Kurhan
      Silver hard case luggage can be ultra-modern with a cool, streamlined appearance.
    • Hard case luggage doesn't easily fit into compartments the way soft luggage does.
      By: xcid
      Hard case luggage doesn't easily fit into compartments the way soft luggage does.
    • A hard case piece of luggage may have rolling wheels that make it easy to transport.
      By: Eugenio Marongiu
      A hard case piece of luggage may have rolling wheels that make it easy to transport.